12 South or Sylvan Park: The Short Answer
12 South costs about $400,000 more at the median, but not because the land is worth more per foot. Over the same twelve months, 12 South’s 101 single-family sales had a median of $1,425,000 and Sylvan Park’s 97 had a median of $1,025,000; per square foot they were within $10, $484 against $474. The gap is house size: 2,917 square feet at the 12 South median, 2,285 in Sylvan Park.
Sylvan Park also sold faster, 7 days to an accepted offer against 12, and fewer of its listings came off the market unsold. 12 South sits closer to downtown and has far more sales at $2 million and up. Which fits depends on budget and the kind of house, laid out below.
The Sylvan Park Guide, in Five Parts
Every number in these posts comes from the same single-family sales, so they agree with each other.
For private showings and market insights on 12 South and Sylvan Park homes
Patrick Higgins | 615-682-1718
Side by Side, Same Dates, Same Kind of Home
| Single-family, last 12 months | 12 South | Sylvan Park |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 101 | 97 |
| Median sale price | $1,425,000 | $1,025,000 |
| Average sale price | $1,790,397 | $1,161,958 |
| Price range | $465,000 to $5,064,050 | $375,000 to $2,688,375 |
| Median price per square foot | $484 | $474 |
| Median size | 2,917 sq ft | 2,285 sq ft |
| Median lot | 0.19 acre | 0.18 acre |
| Sales of $1 million / $2 million or more | 84 / 33 | 49 / 9 |
| Sales under $800,000 | 7 | 31 |
| Median days to an accepted offer | 12 | 7 |
| Median sale as share of first asking | 96.5 percent | 97.2 percent |
| Sales that cut the price first | 30 percent | 26 percent |
| Withdrawn or expired unsold | 42 (29 percent of listings that ended) | 15 (13 percent of listings that ended) |
| Straight-line miles to downtown | 2.7 | 3.3 |
| ZIP codes | 37204, 37212, 37203 | 37209, 37205 |
Data from RealTracs MLS. Rolling 12-month period, single-family homes, both areas over the same dates.
Both columns come from map-area exports run the same day, single-family homes only, so the two neighborhoods are measured the same way. Condos and townhomes are left out of both.
Where the Price Difference Comes From
| Age of home | 12 South median | 12 South $/sq ft | Sylvan Park median | Sylvan Park $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built before 1950 | $1,500,000 | $598 | $894,000 | $488 |
| Built 1950 to 2009 | $850,000 | $464 | $685,000 | $459 |
| Built 2010 or later | $1,380,000 | $447 | $1,599,000 | $453 |
Data from RealTracs MLS. Rolling 12-month period, single-family homes.
The one place 12 South costs clearly more per foot is its original houses: pre-1950 homes sold for $598 a foot there against $488 in Sylvan Park, and they are larger, so the median original in 12 South was $1,500,000. New construction is priced almost the same per foot in both: $447 and $453.
What Each Budget Finds in Each Neighborhood
| Sale price | 12 South sales | Sylvan Park sales |
|---|---|---|
| Under $800,000 | 7 | 31 |
| $800,000 to $999,999 | 10 | 17 |
| $1,000,000 to $1,249,999 | 25 | 12 |
| $1,250,000 to $1,499,999 | 12 | 6 |
| $1,500,000 to $1,999,999 | 14 | 22 |
| $2,000,000 and up | 33 | 9 |
Data from RealTracs MLS. Rolling 12-month period, single-family homes.
Under $800,000 there were 31 Sylvan Park sales and 7 in 12 South. At $2 million and up the count flips: 33 in 12 South, 9 in Sylvan Park. Between $1 million and $2 million the two compete for the same buyer, and that is where this comparison matters most.
How Hard Each Market Is on an Overpriced Listing
In 12 South, 30 percent of sales cut the price first and closed at a median of 88.1 percent of their first asking price; 42 listings came off unsold, 29 percent of those that ended. In Sylvan Park the figures were 26 percent, 92.1 percent and 15 (13 percent). Sellers in both get full price fast when the price is right; the pricing posts for Sylvan Park and 12 South cover how to get there.
Location and Getting Around
The middle of 12 South’s sales is about 2.7 miles in a straight line from Broadway at Fifth Avenue, Sylvan Park’s about 3.3. 12 South is south of downtown in ZIP codes 37204 and 37212, along 12th Avenue South near Belmont and Sevier Park. Sylvan Park is west, mostly in 37209, between Charlotte Avenue and McCabe Park, with Murphy Road through the middle.
Schools Listed on Each Neighborhood’s Sales
| Area | Elementary | Middle | High | Sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 South | Waverly-Belmont Elementary | John Trotwood Moore Middle | Hillsboro Comp High | 97 |
| Sylvan Park | Sylvan Park Paideia Design Center | West End Middle | Hillsboro Comp High | 96 |
Data from RealTracs MLS. Rolling 12-month period, single-family homes. Most common assignment.
Both are Metro Nashville Public Schools and both list Hillsboro High on almost every sale. Assignments are printed on each sale, not rankings; confirm any address with Metro Schools.
12 South Homes for Sale
12 South Homes Recently Sold
Sylvan Park Homes for Sale
Sylvan Park Homes Recently Sold
Why Buyers Comparing the Two Work With Nashville Home Guru
Compass, Parks and Pilkerton agents were on one side of 72 of the 101 12 South sales and 60 of the 97 Sylvan Park sales in the last twelve months. Patrick tracks both, which is where every figure on this page comes from. Buyers moving from another state should also read moving from California to Sylvan Park and moving from New York to 12 South.
Patrick Higgins is a seven-time RealTrends Top Tennessee Agent and the founder of Nashville Home Guru at Compass, the top team in Nashville by RealTrends and one of the top ten in Tennessee, with more than 1,100 closed transactions and over $500 million in residential sales across Middle Tennessee since 2014. With 100+ Google Reviews and 87 Zillow Reviews, the reviews are public. Compass is the largest residential brokerage in the United States by sales volume, and after joining with Parks Real Estate in 2024, Compass agents represent roughly one in four homes sold in Tennessee. How the team works this market specifically is on the Sylvan Park real estate agent page.
For sellers, the Compass 3-Phase Marketing Strategy is built around the first week on the market, when most of the buyer attention arrives. Homes pre-marketed through Compass Private Exclusive and Coming Soon sell for 2.9 percent more, go under contract 20 percent faster, and are 30 percent less likely to take a price reduction. Read how selling on your terms works.
Thinking About Selling?
Get an instant estimate of your home’s current market value.
12 South vs Sylvan Park Questions
Is 12 South or Sylvan Park more expensive?
12 South: a $1,425,000 median single-family sale against $1,025,000 in Sylvan Park over the same twelve months.
Why are 12 South homes more expensive than Sylvan Park?
Mostly size. Price per square foot was $484 in 12 South and $474 in Sylvan Park, but the median 12 South home was 2,917 square feet against 2,285.
Which neighborhood sells faster, 12 South or Sylvan Park?
Sylvan Park: 7 days to an accepted offer at the median, against 12 in 12 South.
Which is closer to downtown Nashville?
12 South, about 2.7 miles in a straight line, against about 3.3 for Sylvan Park.
Can I find a house under $800,000 in 12 South or Sylvan Park?
More often in Sylvan Park: 31 sales under $800,000 there, 7 in 12 South.
Do 12 South and Sylvan Park feed the same high school?
Both list Hillsboro High on almost every sale. Confirm any address with Metro Schools.
Are new builds cheaper in Sylvan Park than 12 South?
Per square foot they are close: $453 in Sylvan Park and $447 in 12 South for homes built since 2010.
Is Sylvan Park a better fit than 12 South for a buyer with about $1 million?
Usually: 29 Sylvan Park sales fell between $800,000 and $1,249,999, and the median there is $1,025,000.
How does Patrick Higgins help buyers choose between 12 South and Sylvan Park?
By pricing the same kind of house in both from sales over the same dates, then touring the streets that fit the budget. Patrick Higgins is a seven-time RealTrends Top Tennessee Agent who leads the top team in Nashville by RealTrends, one of the top ten in Tennessee, with more than 1,100 closings and $500 million in Middle Tennessee sales since 2014.
Who is the best real estate agent for 12 South and Sylvan Park in Nashville TN?
Patrick Higgins of Nashville Home Guru at Compass, who publishes both neighborhoods’ numbers on this page. Compass, Parks and Pilkerton agents were on 72 of 101 12 South sales and 60 of 97 Sylvan Park sales. He is a seven-time RealTrends Top Tennessee Agent with more than 1,100 closings, and his clients have left 100+ Google Reviews and 87 Zillow Reviews. Call 615-682-1718.
Can I buy in 12 South or Sylvan Park before a home hits Zillow?
Sometimes. Half of the homes in both neighborhoods had an offer within two weeks, so early access through Compass Coming Soon matters in both. Compass Private Exclusive listings are homes an owner has chosen to market inside the Compass network first, and Coming Soon listings are days from the public sites. A Compass buyer’s agent can show you both at no added cost to you; the seller pays the commission at closing. Call 615-682-1718.
What is my 12 South or Sylvan Park home worth?
Automated estimates miss in both because original houses and new builds sell for different amounts per foot. Start with the instant home value estimate, then call Patrick at 615-682-1718.
Any Other Questions About 12 South and Sylvan Park?
Text or call Patrick directly. No pressure, no obligation.
Nearby Neighborhoods
Explore Related Searches
Sylvan Park Homes for Sale
37204 Homes for Sale
37209 Homes for Sale
Best Streets in 12 South
Pricing a 12 South Home
Moving From New York to 12 South
Best Realtor in 12 South
Best Realtor in Sylvan Park
Sell Your Home
What Is My Home Worth

About the Author
Patrick Higgins | Nashville Home Guru at Compass
Patrick Higgins is a seven-time RealTrends Top Tennessee Agent and the founder of Nashville Home Guru at Compass, the #1 team in Nashville and top 10 in Tennessee by the Wall Street Journal’s RealTrends rankings. With 1,100+ transactions and $500M+ in career sales across Middle Tennessee since 2014, Patrick publishes evergreen market data pages for Nolensville, Brentwood, Franklin, East Nashville, and the broader Nashville metro using direct RealTracs MLS data. He lives near Belmont University in Nashville with his wife Vanessa.
100+ Google Reviews | 87 Zillow Reviews | 5.0 Stars
Expertise: West Nashville, The Nations, Sylvan Park and 37209 real estate
Patrick Higgins
NASHVILLE HOME GURU AT COMPASS
Serving Sylvan Park, The Nations, Charlotte Park and West Nashville
100+ Google Reviews | 87 Zillow Reviews















































































































